hey hey hey #144, Jug (Cookie Jug), Two sizes., Produced 1958-70 #153, W.C. Fields, "Snack Jar", Produced in 1972-1974 hey hey #33, Bunch of Bananas, , Produced 1948-52 #156, Canister, "Flower Burst", Produced 1972-73 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? hey hey #175, Animal Crackers, , Produced in 1960 hey #28, Wheat on Mother of Pearl Glaze, , Produced in 1961 hey hey hey hey #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 While this guide cannot cover every vintage cookie jar made by McCoy Pottery Co., itll steer you in the right direction. #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 Look at everything when inspecting a supposed vintage McCoy cookie jar. #18, Pear, Basic yellow or aqua., Produced 1952-57 hey hey hey hey hey hey #56, Two Kittens in a Basket, Made in 1950's, Produced in 1950's HILLBILLY BEAR COOKIE JAR - Height unavailable (very rare), HNH Vol. #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 #174, Christmas Tree, Hand decorated., Produced in 1959. See Sold Price. #20, Apple, Red with gold leaf., Produced in 1956-57 hey hey #148, Bear, "Hamm's Bear", Produced 1972 hey #173, Globe, Aqua, Produced 1960-63 hey #158, Burlap Bag, "Two different covers", Produced 1972-77 #137, Teepee, Hand decorated, Produced 1956-59 #128, Dog on basketweave, Black cover, with black cover., Produced in 1956 and 1957 hey hey hey #5, Bean Pot Shape, 6-pint, open handles, hand decorated., Produced in 1939 #157, Fruit in Basket, "Bushel Basket", Produced in 1961 hey hey, #136, Cookie Cabin, Ivory with brown., Produced 1956-60 #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 #170, Drum, , Produced 1960 hey hey #97, Stage Coach, hand decorated., Produced in 1956 Because the demand for sanitary ware declined post-war, the company switched its focus to pottery. #148, Bear, "Hamm's Bear", Produced 1972 hey hey hey #148, Covered Wagon, "Cookies Wagon", Produced 1960-61 #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 #30, Square Jar, hand decorated, Produced in 1947 hey #127, Lamb on Basketweave, Brown cover with brown base., Produced 1956-57 #139, Hen on Nest, Brown hen and yellow nest., Produced 1958-59 #147, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1958-68 hey This is a rare McCoy cookie jar. #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 #41, Elephant, All of trunk on lid., Produced in 1953 #157, Fruit in Basket, "Bushel Basket", Produced in 1961 #143, Bear and Beehive, Hand decorated, Produced 1983-1987, #56, Two Kittens in a Basket, Made in 1950's, Produced in 1950's hey #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 #140, Davy Crockett, Hand decorated., Produced in 1957 hey #137, Teepee, Hand decorated, Produced 1956-59 #152, Barnum's Animals, "Nabisco Wagon", Produced 1972-73 hey hey hey hey hey #134, Apples on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #170, Drum, , Produced 1960 hey #143, Bear and Beehive, Hand decorated, Produced 1983-1987, #52, Pineapple, Natural Colors, Produced 1955-57 #36, Mother Goose, Hand Decorated., Produced 1948-52 hey hey hey hey hey #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 hey #97, Stage Coach, hand decorated., Produced in 1956 hey, #1, Ball Shape, Honey comb design on heavy pottery., Produced in the late '30s hey hey hey #157, Pepper, , Produced 1972-80 #20, Apple, Yellow or aqua., Produced in 1950-64 #148, Covered Wagon, "Cookies Wagon", Produced 1960-61 #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 #41, Elephant, All of trunk on lid., Produced in 1953 #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 Those partners may have their own information theyve collected about you. #142, Bear and Barrel, Hand decorated., Produced in 1978. hey #148, Covered Wagon, "Cookies Wagon", Produced 1960-61 #52, Pineapple, Natural Colors, Produced 1955-57 Welcome to the McCoy Pottery Online's Cookie Jar Index. hey hey #159, Grandma, "Granny", Produced 1972-75 #36, Mother Goose, Hand Decorated., Produced 1948-52 hey #153, W.C. Fields, "Snack Jar", Produced in 1972-1974 #175, Animal Crackers, , Produced in 1960 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 #159, Grandma, "Granny", Produced 1972-75 #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 #151, Cookie House, , Produced 1958-60 #128, Dog on basketweave, Black cover, with black cover., Produced in 1956 and 1957 #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 #40, Clown, In barrel., Produced 1953-55 hey #30, Square Jar, hand decorated, Produced in 1947 hey #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 hey hey hey hey hey #154, Early American Milk Can, , Produced 1972-74 #40, Clown, In barrel., Produced 1953-55 hey #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 Each Cookie Jar is listed by year, not by "Number". hey hey #153, W.C. Fields, "Snack Jar", Produced in 1972-1974 hey #133, Pine Cones on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 hey hey McCoy Coalby the Cat Cookie Jar Estimated Value: $450 Brand or Maker: McCoy Origin: The United States Year Made: 1967 photo source: ebay.com McCoy was founded in 1910, but the brand didn't start making its iconic cookie jars until the 1930s. hey #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 hey #129, Duck on Basketweave, Yellow cover with yellow base, Produced in 1956 #170, Drum, , Produced 1960 #153, W.C. Fields, "Snack Jar", Produced in 1972-1974 #41, Elephant, All of trunk on lid., Produced in 1953 #53, Pumpkin, Jack-o-Lantern, Produced 1955 #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 hey hey hey #142, Bear and Barrel, Hand decorated., Produced in 1978. hey hey hey hey hey #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 #38, Owls, Mr. and Mrs. Owl, Produced 1952-55 #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 Because its primary purpose is to hold cookies and biscuits (or any other suitable item,) damages to the piece would depreciate its value. hey #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 #159, Grandma, "Granny", Produced 1972-75 hey #172, Chipmunk, , Produced 1960-61 hey hey #129, Duck on Basketweave, Yellow cover with yellow base, Produced in 1956 hey hey hey hey #36, Mother Goose, Hand Decorated., Produced 1948-52 #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? #20, Elephant, With split trunk., Produced in 1945 #151, Cookie House, , Produced 1958-60 hey #37, Decorated Honey Bear, On the side of a tree., Produced 1953-55 #156, Canister, "Flower Burst", Produced 1972-73 #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 #158, Gingerbread Boy, "On barrel shape", Produced in 1961 hey #136, Cookie Cabin, Ivory with brown., Produced 1956-60 #159, Grandma, "Granny", Produced 1972-75 #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 hey #156, Canister, "Flower Burst", Produced 1972-73 #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 hey #153, W.C. Fields, "Snack Jar", Produced in 1972-1974 hey hey #157, Pepper, , Produced 1972-80 hey hey hey hey hey hey hey, #21, Barrel Shape, Shape like Dutch Boy cookie jar, Produced in 1945 hey #153, Wren House, "Two Colors", Produced 1958-60 hey #144, Jug (Cookie Jug), Two sizes., Produced 1958-70 #52, Pineapple, Natural Colors, Produced 1955-57 hey hey #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 hey hey #172, Chipmunk, , Produced 1960-61 #36, Mother Goose, Hand Decorated., Produced 1948-52 hey hey, #148, Covered Wagon, "Cookies Wagon", Produced 1960-61 Below: This turtle sprinkler ONLY came in the typical McCoy green. #20, Apple, Red with gold leaf., Produced in 1956-57 #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 Nothing says Halloween like a Jack O lantern, and adding the spooky cookie jar to your house dcor in October isnt a bad idea. hey hey #133, Pine Cones on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #156, Canister, "Flower Burst", Produced 1972-73 hey hey hey hey hey #53, Pumpkin, Jack-o-Lantern, Produced 1955 hey #155, Tulip, "Flower Pot Shape", Produced 1958-59 These colors were mostly fire-glazed and made in earth tones. #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 hey #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 #173, Globe, Aqua, Produced 1960-63 hey #148, Bear, "Hamm's Bear", Produced 1972 #28, Wheat on Mother of Pearl Glaze, , Produced in 1961 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 hey #174, Christmas Tree, Hand decorated., Produced in 1959. #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 #97, Stage Coach, hand decorated., Produced in 1956 #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 #139, Hen on Nest, Brown hen and yellow nest., Produced 1958-59 #138, Floral Cookie Jar, Plain oval shape., Produced 1956-57 #136, Cookie Cabin, Ivory with brown., Produced 1956-60 hey #155, Tulip, "Flower Pot Shape", Produced 1958-59 hey #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 #26, Dutch Boy/Dutch Girl, barrel shape., Produced in 1946 ), #2, Concave Shape, Yellow clay, floral decoration., Produced in the mid '30s hey #157, Pepper, , Produced 1972-80 hey #158, Burlap Bag, "Two different covers", Produced 1972-77 #153, W.C. Fields, "Snack Jar", Produced in 1972-1974 hey #170, Drum, , Produced 1960 #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 hey #134, Apples on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #170, Drum, , Produced 1960 #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 hey hey #138, Floral Cookie Jar, Plain oval shape., Produced 1956-57 #155, Tulip, "Flower Pot Shape", Produced 1958-59 hey #153, Wren House, "Two Colors", Produced 1958-60 hey hey #138, Floral Cookie Jar, Plain oval shape., Produced 1956-57 hey hey #134, Apples on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 hey hey #140, Davy Crockett, Hand decorated., Produced in 1957 hey hey hey hey Even if you dont eat cookies, getting a McCoy Cookie Jar is still a good option for sweets, pet treats, spices, beverages, and many storable items. hey #153, W.C. Fields, "Snack Jar", Produced in 1972-1974 #136, Cookie Cabin, Ivory with brown., Produced 1956-60 hey hey #153, Wren House, "Two Colors", Produced 1958-60 #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 #145, Modern, white with red "Cookies", Produced in 1958 hey #56, Two Kittens in a Basket, Made in 1950's, Produced in 1950's #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 hey #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 hey hey hey hey #148, Covered Wagon, "Cookies Wagon", Produced 1960-61 hey hey hey #50, The Original Pontiac Indian, , Produced from 1954 , I think ? hey #12, Concave Shape, hand decorated., Produced in 1942 hey #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 hey hey hey #152, Barnum's Animals, "Nabisco Wagon", Produced 1972-73 hey McCoy Cookie jars gained popularity amongst homemakers because of their diverse designs. hey hey hey #172, Chipmunk, , Produced 1960-61 #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 #157, Fruit in Basket, "Bushel Basket", Produced in 1961 #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? View Etsys Privacy Policy. hey hey Rare Freddie the Gleep Mccoy Cookie Jar - Etsy hey #152, Barnum's Animals, "Nabisco Wagon", Produced 1972-73 #52, Pineapple, Natural Colors, Produced 1955-57 hey #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 #144, Jug (Cookie Jug), Two sizes., Produced 1958-70 hey hey #133, Pine Cones on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 hey #154, Early American Milk Can, , Produced 1972-74 #152, Barnum's Animals, "Nabisco Wagon", Produced 1972-73 hey #173, Globe, Aqua, Produced 1960-63 #145, Modern, white with red "Cookies", Produced in 1958 #170, Drum, , Produced 1960 #41, Elephant, All of trunk on lid., Produced in 1953 hey hey hey hey hey hey #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 hey #175, Animal Crackers, , Produced in 1960 #136, Cookie Cabin, Ivory with brown., Produced 1956-60 hey #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 hey, #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 hey hey #139, Hen on Nest, Brown hen and yellow nest., Produced 1958-59 Click image for larger view. #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? hey hey #129, Duck on Basketweave, Yellow cover with yellow base, Produced in 1956 hey hey #140, Davy Crockett, Hand decorated., Produced in 1957 #151, Cookie House, , Produced 1958-60 hey #133, Pine Cones on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 hey #34, Hobby Horse, hand decorated., Produced from 1948-53 #135, Pears on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #31, Hexagon Jar, square handles., Produced in 1947